Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marilynne Mellander's avatar

Putin IS a globalist....he should win an Academy Award for his low key deception

Expand full comment
Random Ruminations's avatar

OK. I finally subscribed even though have resisted subsack subscriptions for a while, being a cheapskate. For me, what's going on with Russia and Putin is the single most important open question in world affairs today and I find your substack the most informative in that regard, though haven't yet peeked behind the paywall.

Meanwhile, last week I got the hardcopy version of Peter Myers The Cosmopolitan Empire, subtitled One World but Whose? (Kindle coming out soon apparently.) He has slowly developed a complex explanation of current affairs on his Neither Aryan nor Jew website at https://mailstar.net/index.html which extensively examines four major conspiratorial power networks which sometimes cooperate but usually compete, namely: British (Anglo-American Imperial), Globalist (One world government), Zionist and Green-Left (Trotskyoid - LGBQ etc.). He goes back into the 1800s telling their various tales, analyzing the origins of WWI, the various factions at Versailles, which ones supported or resisted the rise of Hitler, the Bolsheviks, Stalin, Trotsky, and so forth up until the present.

It appears from this kind of perspective and your coverage that Putin is in the Globalist Camp and also sympathetic to the Trotskyoid Green-Left agenda (these two are often, though not always in cahoots).

That said, it also seems to me that he is genuinely a Russian nationalist patriot who is championing the revival of core elements of traditional Russian culture, moreover in resistance to the social engineering side of the Trotskyoid Green-Left crowd (LGBQ etc.) which undermine traditional and family culture.

One can imagine him thusly: a Captain commanding a large ship, say an aircraft carrier, moreover during a revolution. He not only has to answer to his military superiors back home, but also keep track of ongoing and serious political developments. Meanwhile the class war raging in the homeland breaks out on occasion on board his vessel, requiring adroit personnel and command management on his part. Note that he has not created what is essentially a fractious, extremely tricky situation. Not to mention that the above political complexities are connected to world wide machinations and changes. It is a constantly shifting kaleidoscope which requires navigating through treacherous waters filled with ever-changing traps and backlashes of all sorts from both domestic and foreign turmoil.

Now obviously Putin is a strong, not a weak, person, moreover one that can hold a point of view over time, articulate and follow it to an unusual degree. Is he making mistakes? Almost certainly. Is there a gap between how his followers describe him hagiographically - especially in Western alternative media - and the reality? Almost certainly. But what I want to know is that, given what a mess Russia was when he took over, no longer Tzarist or communist etc., where is should he have headed, how well has he done in that regard, and where is he headed now?

This question presupposes that he is a strong, competent leader whether or not you agree with his policies. But perhaps you think that is not the case? Or if you agree, what do you think he is pushing towards (for good or ill)? If much of the CBDC stuff is misguided, as you maintain (and I would agree btw), why is he doing it, what is his goal? Is he being duped or is he a Bad Actor? Or is he perhaps compromised and has little agency to prevent that sort of thing?

If compromised, does that make his entire Presidency a puppet's performance? If so, who is holding the strings? Or is he playing for time or compromising here and there but meanwhile still managing to steer his Ship of State in a fundamentally good direction (as I still suspect might be the case)?

Much of what he says in his speeches feels solid, reasonable, purposeful, honorable and principled moreover surprisingly consistent over two decades now and counting. I find it hard to discount all these positive qualities as performative deceptions. I am not against your thrust - hence the subscription - but I still have questions, perhaps feeling there is more nuance and depth needed to get a more complete picture of what Russia is these days, where it is headed, what are the major points of disagreement and debate, and what role Putin is playing therein, both well and poorly.

Thank you for your substack.

Expand full comment
100 more comments...

No posts